When AI gets VAT wrong, you pay the penalty: why VAT expert oversight matters.

Related Expertise:

Duration
3 min read
Published
Table of contents

Pedro Barbosa

VAT manager

There is a familiar pattern: a new technology or a new tool appears promising to make all the complexity simpler, cheaper to handle, or removed altogether. Large language model (LLM, what most of us simply call AI) agents are the current example, and every department is under pressure to adopt and deliver the promises: faster processes, more automation, fewer errors, improved reporting and lower costs. 

Now, we are not suggesting the promises are not real. They very much are… but they need to be carefully managed. 

VAT is one area where the potential benefits are obvious, while the dangers may not be. Compliance carries so much administrative burden that, if AI can reduce it, the case for using is compelling. The risk is when efficiency is confused with accuracy. 

VAT rules can be detailed, full of exceptions, they frequently change and are highly dependent on interpretation. The correct treatment of a transaction depends on who the customer is, how the contract is worded, what the product is, how it is used, what local tax authorities expect in practice, etc. These are not always questions with simple mechanical answers. 

Nonetheless, the LLM you use will often produce an answer that sounds authoritative. It will include caveats such as “subject to applicable rules” or “information should be reviewed”, but this cautious language is not evidence of a cautious reasoning. What the tool doesn’t tell you is that it may searched only a handful of sources, without reviewing reliability, didn’t check if specific information is still current, that it may overlook exceptions or contradictions just to deliver a coherent narrative. 

There is no real debate whether AI will replace VAT professionals – because it simply cannot! Not even to write this article, we promise. AI agents are exceptionally suited to summarize information, draft reports and helping someone navigate loads of data. They are useful assistants, but not a substitute for critical analysis and experience. Wrong answers can be an inconvenience in other business areas, but in VAT that means penalties, audits and difficult conversations with tax authorities. 

We are seeing consequences of ill-advised use of AI more and more often in our work. Just recently a multinational business approached us with, what it seems, a plain question: “how should it invoice between two companies in its group?”. They had already made decisions about their business model and proposed supply chain. They presented us lovely slides, figures and detailed “research”. It just had a one problem – what looked clean operationally was a VAT nightmare. Their favourite AI model did not identify the risk. In fact, several considerations had been missed. We are now working to disentangle the consequences. 

This is precisely where professional judgment matters: to examine the underlying transactions and assumptions, understand the business operations and assess the VAT implications before decisions are made. The AI agents then enter the picture to support this work because VAT professionals who use them wisely will set a much higher standard than those who do not. 

The strongest model is therefore not one of competition between automation and expertise. It’s looks more like a division of responsibilities. Technology handles the repeatable tasks and identifies relevant data, and experienced professionals interpret the facts, challenge assumptions, and manage the positions the business takes. 

Yes, AI models are to be used, because the future of VAT compliance will never be manual again, but it’s not fully automated as of now. The future will be enabled by technology, driven by data but led by experts. Before relying on AI-generated VAT advice to make a business decision, speak to Leyton.

Our VAT experts combine practical, cross-border experience with technology-enabled tools to help you move faster, without overlooking the risks that matter.

Ready for the next step?

Book a Free Assessment

Ready to accelerate your transformation? Schedule a 30-minute scoping session with one of our specialized partners to discuss your current challenges.